• News
    • Bitcoin
    • Altcoins
    • Blockchain
    • DeFi
    • Regulation
    • Scams
  • NFT
  • Metaverse
  • Analysis
  • Learn
  • Videos
  • Blogs
  • Market Cap
  • Shop
What's Hot

What Is a DEX? How DEXs Work and Why They Matter

2025-05-21

What Is Blockchain? Blockchain Technology Explained for Beginners

2025-05-21

OCTA: 🚀 The Craziest 🔥 BULLISH 📈 Signals EVER 🤯

2025-05-20

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

Facebook Twitter Instagram
Crypto Investor News Network
  • News
    • Bitcoin
    • Altcoins
    • Blockchain
    • DeFi
    • Regulation
    • Scams
  • NFT

    All Eyes on Art: Upcoming Collections to Watch the Week of February 4

    2025-02-05

    Creator of rabbit AI assistant has hidden NFT past

    2024-05-02

    Ethereum tops daily NFT sales at US$7 mln, ends weakest month of 2024

    2024-05-02

    Top NFT Airdrops and Giveaways for May 2024

    2024-05-02

    Casio Launches NFT Collection Celebrating 50th Anniversary

    2024-05-01
  • Metaverse

    Shib: The Metaverse – Part of the Expanding Shiba Inu Ecosystem

    2025-01-03

    Experience to Earn: Everdome’s Metaverse Frontier

    2024-12-30

    Beyond Bots: Meta Motivo and the Dawn of Humanlike Digital Life

    2024-12-13

    Exploring NetVRk: What Is Behind This AI-Driven Virtual Universe?

    2024-10-28

    Council of Europe Highlights Metaverse’s Impact on Privacy and Democracy

    2024-09-05
  • Analysis

    Crypto Exchange Coinbase Lists New DeFi Altcoin Project Built on Base Blockchain

    2023-12-13

    Ethereum Price Bears Keep Pushing, Why Decline Isn’t Over Yet

    2023-12-13

    Trader Bullish on Cosmos (ATOM), Says One Dogecoin Rival Setting Up for Next Leg Up – Here’s His Outlook

    2023-12-13

    AVAX Price Pumps 50% and Dumps 15%, Why Uptrend Is Still Strong

    2023-12-13

    Top Trader Predicts Parabolic Rally for Solana Competitor – Here’s His Upside Target

    2023-12-13
  • Learn

    What Is a DEX? How DEXs Work and Why They Matter

    2025-05-21

    What Is Blockchain? Blockchain Technology Explained for Beginners

    2025-05-21

    A Beginner’s Guide to Crypto

    2025-05-15

    10 Years of Steadfast Support and Compliance

    2025-05-15

    What Is Proof-of-Work (PoW) in Blockchain? A Beginner-Friendly Guide

    2025-05-12
  • Videos

    OCTA: 🚀 The Craziest 🔥 BULLISH 📈 Signals EVER 🤯

    2025-05-20

    ALL IN! 10X Bitcoin leverage RIGHT NOW!!

    2025-05-19

    Bitcoin: Buy Now, 10X Leverage!!!!!

    2025-05-19

    Bitcoin’s Highest Weekly Close Signals Bigger Moves Ahead

    2025-05-19

    Bitcoin ATH Countdown: Record Price Breakout Imminent

    2025-05-18
  • Blogs
  • Market Cap
  • Shop
Facebook Twitter Instagram TikTok
Crypto Investor News Network
Home»NFT»Yuga Labs’ intensifying IP takedowns spur CryptoPunk backlash
NFT

Yuga Labs’ intensifying IP takedowns spur CryptoPunk backlash

2023-07-18No Comments6 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

Months after a US court handed Yuga Labs a hefty trademark-based legal victory that set NFT holders abuzz, questions have once again swirled around the precedent it set — and what it means for current holders and creators of top crypto collectibles.

Another instance of Yuga Labs, the Miami-headquartered Web3 company that owns blue-chip NFT collections CryptoPunks and Bored Ape Yacht Club (BAYC), looking to enforce its intellectual property rights, has attracted industry attention.

Tom Lehman, the creator of the Ethscriptions Protocol, which provides a mechanism to attach image files on-chain, tweeted last week that he had taken down Ethereum Punk images from the protocol’s website and was “taking down” the Ethereum Punks’ website outright.

Lehman, who goes by MiddleMarch on Twitter and did not return a request for comment, said he was doing so “at the request of Yuga Labs.”

Amidst the flurry of NFT legal actions, Brian Frye, a professor at the University of Kentucky College of Law who has followed the issue closely, said it’s “really important to distinguish between specifically copyright and trademark when it comes to the copyright issues in the space.”

The latter issues, especially, seem to be showing few signs of stopping.

A series of tweets on July 15 from the Ethereum Punks collection said Yuga Labs had undertaken “recent DMCA actions,” which the collection said were “arguably indicative of a corporate mindset and directly challenge the foundational ideals of the PUNK community.”

The spirit of PUNK is predominantly rooted in values such as nonconformity, anti-authoritarianism, anti-corporatism, a DIY ethos, resistance to consumerism and corporate greed, direct action, and an unwavering commitment to never “sell out”.

— Ethereum Punks (@ethscribedpunks) July 15, 2023

The tweets did not specify the DMCA enforcement actions in question, but framed Yuga Labs’ actions as “corporate greed.” A spokesperson for the company did not return a request for comment.

See also  STARSPACE NFT Marketplace is Set to Launch on Aptos

On the copyright front, “nothing about owning an NFT makes you any kind of copyright owner at all,” Frye said. “Trademark is a value associated with NFT projects…the real value is owning the token.”

Ethscriptions, which was hacked last week, has billed itself as a decentralized protocol (not its own blockchain or layer-2) based in the Ethereum ecosystem. Approximately 123 wallet addresses were said to have lost 202 ethscriptions in the hack.

Jessica Neer McDonald, an attorney specializing in intellectual property issues, told Blockworks that, generally speaking, discretion when it comes to usage terms can vary widely, hinging upon the issuer of the NFT collection.

“It’s so specific to the collection,” McDonald told Blockworks. “Each collection has the ability to provide — at least traditionally — licenses and permissions to use certain artwork that’s connected to a certain NFT, and that permission can really range to you’re only being given the right to personal usage versus expanding it to using it for commercial reasons.”

Yuga Labs NFT case against Ripps still rolling

Much of the current uncertainty has stemmed from a lawsuit Yuga Labs brought against Ryder Ripps and Jeremy Cahen, the creators “Ryder Ripps Bored Ape Yacht Club,” a satirical NFT collection impugning Bored Ape Yacht Club.

A judge overseeing the US court case, which centers around the near mirror-image NFTs, put an injunction in place against the collection, ruling in Yuga Labs’ favor and imposing monetary damages on the defendants.

At issue then was not so much copyrights, which would have been tied to individual artworks of each NFT, but trademarks.

See also  Activewear and Luxury Brands Embrace Web3 Innovation

“I think it was smart for Yuga’s strategy to focus on the trademarks and not get caught up on the copyright side,” McDonald said. “There’s still a lot of unanswered questions in relation to copyright: What does it mean to get an NFT? What do you get when you buy an NFT?”

While copyrights, in a Bored Ape Yacht Club example, would refer to rights to the image depicted in a given NFT, trademarks protect the likeness and defining characteristics of the collection more broadly — which experts say are what Yuga Labs has really been looking to lock down.

BAYC holders have extensive commercialization rights, including merchandise and side media projects. It’s unclear what would happen to those endeavors if an NFT is sold.

“If you think about it — to the extent you think copyright can protect the individual images in the first place — it’s not really obvious to me how owning the copyright to one of 1,000 images, well, I don’t know how valuable that is.” Frye said.

‘Copyright doesn’t protect URLs’

Bored Ape Yacht Club holders do have extensive rights to launch commercialized endeavors around their NFTs — as long as they still own them. Past interpretations have pointed to owners having the right to make money off of their apes, including via rolling out their own merchandising.

And no caps on that monetization were initially implied, meaning owners ought to have unlimited runway with their side-hustle projects. Yuga Labs has taken a stand against what the company has deemed as ripoff or competitive projects — not so much how its NFT owners are using their own digital property.

See also  NFT Trader Accidentally Burns $129K CryptoPunk

From a copyright perspective, according to University of Kentucky’s Frye, exchanging an inscribed NFT onchain, or even simply storing one in a wallet, “doesn’t really” present issues, which is one reason copyright violations haven’t been a big legal focus in these kinds of disputes.

That’s because “copyright doesn’t protect URL,” and while it “might be infringing to a point to host the image on a file server,” what’s “inscribed on the blockchain is not infringing and can’t be infringing.”

The sentiment, in Frye’s estimation, applies to most such digital collectibles like Ordinals that are using three to four megabytes of data to add inscriptions. NFTs going significantly above those limits or making substantial changes to the original file could shift that calculation.

CryptoPunks’ terms of service point out that NFT buyers own the NFT itself as long as it’s in their wallet, but Yuga Labs maintains ownership of the intellectual property at play, which the company says is provided to buyers under a “license.”

The terms of service reference the possibility of “derivative” works, which users could create (and own the fresh intellectual property), but there are restrictions around ownership and other thorny legalities at work.

Backlash CryptoPunk intensifying Labs spur takedowns Yuga
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

Related Posts

All Eyes on Art: Upcoming Collections to Watch the Week of February 4

2025-02-05

How Tether, TRON, TRM Labs froze $100 million in stolen digital assets

2025-01-02

Binance Labs’ Recent Investment: What is OpenEden?

2024-09-23

Ethena Labs Launches sENA, Boosting Liquidity and DeFi Rewards

2024-09-18
Add A Comment

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Top Posts
Regulation

Do Kwon Must Stay Two More Months in Montenegro as Authorities Extend Custody Period: Report

2023-12-12

Terra (LUNA) founder Do Kwon is staying in Montenegrin custody for at least two more…

Videos

More Bitcoin Magazine Stinky Cheese

2024-04-16

In this video, I discuss Bitcoin Magazine’s continued ideological drift towards supporting shipcoins, including a…

Bitcoin

Chainlink surges 15% in a week as Bitcoin and Ethereum lag behind

2023-09-24

Journalist Posted: September 24, 2023 LINK ranks as the crypto asset with the most gains…

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news and Update from CINN about Crypto, Metaverse and NFT.

Editors Picks

What Is a DEX? How DEXs Work and Why They Matter

2025-05-21

What Is Blockchain? Blockchain Technology Explained for Beginners

2025-05-21

OCTA: 🚀 The Craziest 🔥 BULLISH 📈 Signals EVER 🤯

2025-05-20

ALL IN! 10X Bitcoin leverage RIGHT NOW!!

2025-05-19
Crypto Investor News Network
Facebook Twitter Instagram TikTok
  • Contact
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Disclouser
© 2025 - All rights are reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

bitcoin
Bitcoin (BTC) $ 111,456.86
ethereum
Ethereum (ETH) $ 2,655.31
tether
Tether (USDT) $ 1.00
xrp
XRP (XRP) $ 2.43
bnb
BNB (BNB) $ 686.90
solana
Solana (SOL) $ 178.50
usd-coin
USDC (USDC) $ 1.00
dogecoin
Dogecoin (DOGE) $ 0.241726
cardano
Cardano (ADA) $ 0.805879
tron
TRON (TRX) $ 0.27803
bitcoin
Bitcoin (BTC) $ 111,456.86
ethereum
Ethereum (ETH) $ 2,655.31
tether
Tether (USDT) $ 1.00
xrp
XRP (XRP) $ 2.43
bnb
BNB (BNB) $ 686.90
solana
Solana (SOL) $ 178.50
usd-coin
USDC (USDC) $ 1.00
dogecoin
Dogecoin (DOGE) $ 0.241726
cardano
Cardano (ADA) $ 0.805879
tron
TRON (TRX) $ 0.27803