• News
    • Bitcoin
    • Altcoins
    • Blockchain
    • DeFi
    • Regulation
    • Scams
  • NFT
  • Metaverse
  • Analysis
  • Learn
  • Videos
  • Blogs
  • Market Cap
  • Shop
What's Hot

Terrorist Attack Coming To The US?

2025-06-17

ZachXBT warns suspected ZKasino fraudster may be linked to new crypto venture WhiteRock

2025-06-16

Crypto’s Going MAINSTREAM… The Signs Are All Here!

2025-06-15

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

Facebook Twitter Instagram
Crypto Investor News Network
  • News
    • Bitcoin
    • Altcoins
    • Blockchain
    • DeFi
    • Regulation
    • Scams
  • NFT

    All Eyes on Art: Upcoming Collections to Watch the Week of February 4

    2025-02-05

    Creator of rabbit AI assistant has hidden NFT past

    2024-05-02

    Ethereum tops daily NFT sales at US$7 mln, ends weakest month of 2024

    2024-05-02

    Top NFT Airdrops and Giveaways for May 2024

    2024-05-02

    Casio Launches NFT Collection Celebrating 50th Anniversary

    2024-05-01
  • Metaverse

    Shib: The Metaverse – Part of the Expanding Shiba Inu Ecosystem

    2025-01-03

    Experience to Earn: Everdome’s Metaverse Frontier

    2024-12-30

    Beyond Bots: Meta Motivo and the Dawn of Humanlike Digital Life

    2024-12-13

    Exploring NetVRk: What Is Behind This AI-Driven Virtual Universe?

    2024-10-28

    Council of Europe Highlights Metaverse’s Impact on Privacy and Democracy

    2024-09-05
  • Analysis

    Crypto Exchange Coinbase Lists New DeFi Altcoin Project Built on Base Blockchain

    2023-12-13

    Ethereum Price Bears Keep Pushing, Why Decline Isn’t Over Yet

    2023-12-13

    Trader Bullish on Cosmos (ATOM), Says One Dogecoin Rival Setting Up for Next Leg Up – Here’s His Outlook

    2023-12-13

    AVAX Price Pumps 50% and Dumps 15%, Why Uptrend Is Still Strong

    2023-12-13

    Top Trader Predicts Parabolic Rally for Solana Competitor – Here’s His Upside Target

    2023-12-13
  • Learn

    What Is Fully Diluted Valuation (FDV) in Crypto?

    2025-06-12

    What Does FUD Mean in Crypto? The Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt Effect

    2025-06-09

    What Is Crypto Staking? How to Earn Crypto by Holding It

    2025-06-05

    What Are Liquidity Pools? A Guide to DeFi Explained Simply

    2025-06-05

    What Is Yield Farming in Crypto? A Beginner’s Guide to DeFi Income

    2025-06-02
  • Videos

    Terrorist Attack Coming To The US?

    2025-06-17

    Crypto’s Going MAINSTREAM… The Signs Are All Here!

    2025-06-15

    How and When Do I Take Bitcoin Profits? | Top Altcoins

    2025-06-14

    Why BTC Might Explode to $150K 🌕

    2025-06-14

    Why Bitcoin Core Is Bitcoin

    2025-06-14
  • Blogs
  • Market Cap
  • Shop
Facebook Twitter Instagram TikTok
Crypto Investor News Network
Home»NFT»What Happens to Football NFTs Now That Panini Lost its License?
NFT

What Happens to Football NFTs Now That Panini Lost its License?

2023-08-23No Comments6 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

NFL Players Association terminated its deal with Italian collectibles company Panini three years early in favor of rival Fanatics.

Panini might chose to keep its NFT markets open, though there probably won’t be a mint happening anytime soon.

An escalating legal war between two top sports card companies is prompting questions about how digital collectibles like NFTs fit into the mix.

This week the NFL Players Association terminated its deal with Italian collectibles company Panini S.p.A three years early in favor of rival Fanatics.

“Effective immediately, Fanatics has the exclusive right to make NFLPA-branded trading cards,” the statement reads. It’s almost certainly focused on the multi-million dollar market for cardboard sports cards. What’s less clear is how this sudden reneging could impact Panini’s pro-football-themed NFTs.

The NFL Players Association did not immediately respond to an email from CoinDesk.

Fanatics has made its mark in the trading card business via licensing deals with the MLB, NBA, and NFLPA, and purchasing Topps – another trading card company – for $500 million, leading to an ongoing legal conflict with Panini.

But what does this mean for the minted NFL NFTs?

Not a lot, explains Ross Feingold, special counsel at Taipei-based Titan Attorneys-at-Law.

The first sale doctrine, explains Feingold, outlines that the owner of a legal copy of a copyrighted work has a right to display, lend, sell, or even dispose of that copy without the permission of the copyright owner.

“I could draw a mustache on Shohei Ohtani on [a baseball card], and then put it on eBay and sell it,” Feingold said. “Fanatics can’t come after me for infringement.”

See also  Ubisoft's 'Champions Tactics' Ethereum NFTs Generate Millions After Free Mint

So don’t expect the Panini-minted NFTs to vanish anytime soon. The company didn’t immediately return a request for comment from CoinDesk.

The trading card industrial complex spent a lot of time in court in the 1990s as licenses and limits of the first sale doctrine were tested. Feingold points to a few pivotal cases from that time as creating the legal framework that will guide arguments in court, should a dispute over NFL NFTs ever make it before a judge.

Over the years, and up into the early 2010s, there have been a number of court cases that have investigated the intersection between the right of publicity – the ability for an individual to have the exclusive rights to monetize their likeness – intellectual property ownership of team logos, and the right of first sale.

Feingold points out that trading card companies used to simply ignore intellectual property conventions and licenses, leading to a wild west of trading cards that might have had the blessing of the players’ association, but not the league, vice versa, or none of the above.

A Continually Evolving Legal Issue

As Attorney Paul Lesko argued in his Law of Cards column from 2013, this is anything but a cut-and-dry field.

There have been several notable lawsuits, such as Kareem-Abdul Jabbar v. Upper Deck and Buzz Aldrin v. Topps, Lesko writes, which have taken place but have not provided clear guidance on when manufacturers must pay for the inclusion of athletes or celebrities in their products.

Lesko points to a 2013 decision from the Ninth Circuit, involving Electronic Arts related to its NCAA Football series of video games, which has furthered the debate, and, arguably, it might ultimately support unlicensed use in the trading card industry.

See also  Non-Fungible Items; Picking up Where NFTs Left off — COZ Co-Founder Tyler Adams

The court’s reasoning, Lesko writes, emphasizes the importance of reporting factual data and historical events and differentiates this from other commercial uses, like video games, where the likeness of individuals is employed without explicit permission.

If there’s one takeaway, it’s that the right of publicity in the trading card industry is a complex and highly litigated matter, and the uniqueness of different right of publicity laws in all 50 states creates a minefield.

NFTs Might Make Things Specifically Complicated

Generally speaking, the first sale doctrine would prevent these now-unlicensed NFTs from vanishing into the ether.

But what if the first sale doctrine regarding NFTs itself was something that’s not yet iron-clad?

A February 2023 paper from legal scholar Joshua Durham, published in the Wake Forest University Journal of Business & Intellectual Property Law, argues that the NFT landscape is evolving faster than the law.

“There is no “digital first sale” doctrine. So NFT creators could legally claw back secondary sales, under current law, leaving you with nothing,” he wrote on X.

In the digital world, a first-sale doctrine requires that the same file can’t exist twice. In crypto parlance, the file can’t be double spent – which blockchain prevents.

But the law hasn’t caught up with the times.

The U.S. Copyright Office has rejected the idea of a “digital first sale” due to the impossibility of confirming the deletion of the original file.

“Policymakers have concluded that since digital transmissions required reproducing a copy of a file (the work), digital transmissions infringed on the exclusive right of reproduction,” Durham writes. “A digital distribution of a reproduced copy was thus unlawfully made, and beyond the scope of the first sale doctrine.”

See also  11 classic memes that have been sold as NFTs

In theory, NFTs would offer a true digital first-sale, but “any unscrupulous NFT creator may invalidate all secondary sales of their NFTs through the outdated reading of [the law],” Durham writes.

Will Anything Actually Happen?

Given how the sports card market has typically played fast-and-loose with traditional understandings of copyright law and monetization, which has in turn opened up a legal gray area, Feingold doesn’t think much will happen.

Panini might even keep its markets open, though you probably won’t see a mint happening anytime soon.

“If Fanatics claims damages because of these NFTs, what are the damages? What did they take from you?” he said. “There’s always been an aftermarket for sports cards, like buying Mickey Mantle rookie cards. That’s the whole point of any collectible.”

Hypothetical damages would be dependent on the success of the business, which on-chain data suggests is far behind its paper counterpart.

‘Signed’ NFTs of Dallas Cowboys’ Tony Romo are going for a floor price of $6 on Panini’s NFT marketplace while their paper-based equivalents have an opening ask of $600 on eBay.

In January, CoinDesk reported that Fanatics is selling its 60% stake in sports-focused NFT company Candy Digital. Is it that they want to hit a kill switch entirely on the vertical and vanish these NFTs entirely?

Or, they could continue business as usual – license be damned – Feingold muses, and later pay out a settlement.

It’s happened before.

Football license Lost NFTs Panini
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

Related Posts

Phantom Wallet Tutorial 2025: Setup, Swaps, NFTs & Airdrop Potential!

2025-05-14

ZachXBT reveals Coinbase users lost another $45M in a week to ongoing social engineering scams

2025-05-07

Bybit Hack 1.4 Billion ETH lost!!!!

2025-02-21

All Eyes on Art: Upcoming Collections to Watch the Week of February 4

2025-02-05
Add A Comment

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Top Posts
NFT

Coinbase Forges Ahead Despite Lackluster NFT Marketplace Rollout

2023-03-04

NFT When most people think of Coinbase, the decade-old publicly traded crypto company, product innovation…

Altcoins

Arbitrum announces launch of ARB token, but here’s the caveat

2023-03-17

The ARB token will be airdropped to eligible community members on 23 March. The number…

Videos

Bitcoin and OTC Trading Desks (How It Really Works)

2023-09-28

Join Bitcoin University Premium: https://www.bitcoinuniversity.com In this video, I discuss how OTC trading desks work,…

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news and Update from CINN about Crypto, Metaverse and NFT.

Editors Picks

Terrorist Attack Coming To The US?

2025-06-17

ZachXBT warns suspected ZKasino fraudster may be linked to new crypto venture WhiteRock

2025-06-16

Crypto’s Going MAINSTREAM… The Signs Are All Here!

2025-06-15

How and When Do I Take Bitcoin Profits? | Top Altcoins

2025-06-14
Crypto Investor News Network
Facebook Twitter Instagram TikTok
  • Contact
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Disclouser
© 2025 - All rights are reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

bitcoin
Bitcoin (BTC) $ 104,705.05
ethereum
Ethereum (ETH) $ 2,512.37
tether
Tether (USDT) $ 1.00
xrp
XRP (XRP) $ 2.14
bnb
BNB (BNB) $ 645.25
solana
Solana (SOL) $ 146.43
usd-coin
USDC (USDC) $ 1.00
tron
TRON (TRX) $ 0.269641
dogecoin
Dogecoin (DOGE) $ 0.168704
staked-ether
Lido Staked Ether (STETH) $ 2,513.16
bitcoin
Bitcoin (BTC) $ 104,705.05
ethereum
Ethereum (ETH) $ 2,512.37
tether
Tether (USDT) $ 1.00
xrp
XRP (XRP) $ 2.14
bnb
BNB (BNB) $ 645.25
solana
Solana (SOL) $ 146.43
usd-coin
USDC (USDC) $ 1.00
tron
TRON (TRX) $ 0.269641
dogecoin
Dogecoin (DOGE) $ 0.168704
staked-ether
Lido Staked Ether (STETH) $ 2,513.16